Water Hardness in Winona, Minnesota
Does Winona have hard water?
Yes, very. This is among the harder municipal supplies in the country.
City of Winona Utilities delivers water at 320 ppm (18.7 grains per gallon), which this site rates Very Hard and the USGS classifies as very hard (over 180 mg/L as calcium carbonate). That is 110 ppm harder than the Minnesota average of 210 ppm, and harder than 95% of the 428 cities listed on this site.
320 PPM in Every Unit
Appliance manuals, test strips and utility reports each use a different hardness unit. These are the same Winona reading expressed in each one.
| Unit | Winona | Used by |
|---|---|---|
| mg/L as CaCO₃ (ppm) | 320 | Utility water-quality reports, USGS |
| Grains per gallon (gpg) | 18.7 | Softener sizing, most US dishwasher manuals, test strips |
| German degrees (°dH) | 17.9 | European-made dishwashers and coffee machines |
| French degrees (°fH) | 32 | Some filter and descaler instructions |
| mmol/L | 3.2 | Laboratory reports |
Dishwasher setting for Winona: 18.7 gpg or 17.9 °dH, rounded up to the machine's nearest step. The USGS bands are soft 0–60, moderately hard 61–120, hard 121–180 and very hard above 180 mg/L; this site splits the top band at 250 to separate hard from very hard.
What 320 PPM Does in a Winona Home
At 320 ppm the supply is among the harder municipal water in the country. Scale restricts fixtures within a year or two, tankless heaters are at real risk of plugging, and bathing leaves skin and hair feeling dry. A softener is close to a necessity rather than an upgrade.
Water heaters
The clearest measured effects of hardness come from a 2009 study the Water Quality Research Foundation commissioned from the Battelle Institute. Scaled to Winona's 18.7 gpg, its gas storage-heater results work out as follows; softened water held full efficiency in the same tests.
| Appliance | Battelle finding | At 18.7 gpg |
|---|---|---|
| Gas storage heater, 50 gal hot water/day | 4% efficiency loss per 5 gpg over 15 years | 15% loss |
| Gas storage heater, 100 gal/day | 8% per 5 gpg, capped at the 48% measured at 30 gpg | 30% loss |
| Electric storage heater | 0.4 lb of scale per year per 5 gpg | 1.5 lb/year |
| Tankless gas heater | Plugged with scale after 1.6 years on 26 gpg water | Descale yearly or soften |
| Showerheads | Lost 75% of flow in under 18 months on hard water | Expect visible scaling within a year |
Laundry and dishes
Hardness minerals bind with detergent before it can clean, which is why dose charts step up for hard water. For Winona: Use the label's heavy-soil or hard-water dose. Softening the water lets you drop back to the minimum dose.
Sizing a Water Softener for Winona
Softener capacity is the grains of hardness a unit removes between regenerations. At 18.7 gpg, each person using 75 gallons a day adds about 1,403 grains daily. The table assumes one regeneration a week and an efficient salt setting of 1 lb per 3,000 grains.
| Household | Grains/day | Grains/7 days | Suggested capacity | Salt/month |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 people | 2,805 | 19,635 | 24,000 grain | ~34 lb |
| 3 people | 4,208 | 29,456 | 32,000 grain | ~46 lb |
| 4 people | 5,610 | 39,270 | 40,000 grain | ~57 lb |
| 5 people | 7,013 | 49,091 | 64,000 grain | ~92 lb |
Add iron at 1 gpg per 1 ppm of dissolved iron if your test shows any, and size up rather than down: a unit that regenerates less often uses less salt per grain removed.
Where Winona's Water Comes From
City of Winona Utilities supplies Winona from groundwater drawn from wells. Groundwater picks up calcium and magnesium as it moves through limestone, dolomite and chalk, which is why well-fed systems are usually harder than river-fed ones.
The supply has a pH of 7.9, inside the EPA secondary range of 6.5–8.5, and total dissolved solids of 520 mg/L, above the EPA secondary standard of 500 mg/L, so a mineral or salty taste and deposits are likely. Hardness is the largest part of dissolved solids in most municipal water, which is why the two tend to rise together.
The figure on this page is the utility's reported average. Blended systems vary by season and neighborhood, so for the current number check the utility's Consumer Confidence Report, which the EPA indexes at Find Your Local CCR, or test the tap with a strip kit.
Treatment Options for 320 PPM
Ranked for Winona's hardness level. Only the first group actually removes calcium and magnesium; conditioners and descalers change how scale behaves without lowering the reading.
Other Cities in Minnesota
Winona ranks 1 of 9 listed Minnesota cities, hardest first. Hardness tracks geology and source more than distance, so neighboring cities can differ widely.
| City | Hardness (PPM) | GPG | Level | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Winona | 320 ppm | 18.7 | Very Hard | Ground |
| St. Cloud | 310 ppm | 18.1 | Very Hard | Ground |
| Rochester | 290 ppm | 17 | Very Hard | Ground |
| Mankato | 270 ppm | 15.8 | Very Hard | Ground |
| Moorhead | 210 ppm | 12.3 | Hard | Surface |
| Bloomington | 150 ppm | 8.8 | Moderately Hard | Mixed |
| St. Paul | 130 ppm | 7.6 | Moderately Hard | Mixed |
| Minneapolis | 120 ppm | 7 | Slightly Hard | Surface |
| Duluth | 45 ppm | 2.6 | Soft | Surface |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Winona have hard water?
Yes, very. This is among the harder municipal supplies in the country. Winona's water measures 320 ppm (18.7 grains per gallon), which the USGS classifies as very hard (over 180 mg/L as calcium carbonate). That is 110 ppm harder than the Minnesota average of 210 ppm and harder than 95% of the 428 cities listed on this site.
What is the water hardness in Winona in grains per gallon?
18.7 grains per gallon. The same 320 mg/L reading is 17.9 German degrees (°dH), 32 French degrees (°fH) and 3.2 mmol/L; 1 grain per gallon equals 17.1 mg/L as calcium carbonate.
Do I need a water softener in Winona?
For most households, yes. At 320 ppm the Battelle Institute's water-heater study implies a gas storage heater loses roughly 15% of its efficiency over 15 years at 50 gallons of hot water a day and 30% at 100 gallons, and fixtures scale within months. A salt-based softener removes the hardness; a salt-free conditioner only limits where the scale sticks.
What size water softener does a family of four need in Winona?
About 40,000 grains. Four people at 75 gallons each per day remove 5,610 grains of hardness daily, or 39,270 grains between weekly regenerations, so the smallest standard unit that covers a week is 40,000 grains. Expect roughly 57.2 lb of salt a month at an efficient setting.
What hardness setting should my dishwasher use in Winona?
Set it for 18.7 grains per gallon, or 17.9 °dH if the manual uses German degrees; most machines take the nearest step up. The setting controls how much rinse aid and, on models with a built-in softener, how much salt the machine uses.
Where does Winona's water come from?
City of Winona Utilities supplies Winona from groundwater drawn from wells. Groundwater picks up calcium and magnesium as it moves through limestone, dolomite and chalk, which is why well-fed systems are usually harder than river-fed ones. The utility's annual Consumer Confidence Report lists the current hardness, pH and dissolved solids; the EPA keeps a finder for these reports.
How does Winona compare with other cities in Minnesota?
Winona ranks 1 of 9 Minnesota cities listed here, hardest first, and is 110 ppm harder than the Minnesota average of 210 ppm. Nationally it is harder than 95% of the 428 cities listed on this site; the median listed city is 125 ppm.
How This Page Works
- The hardness, pH, dissolved-solids, source and utility values are the figures reported by City of Winona Utilities; every other number on the page is arithmetic on them. The site's five-band scale (soft, slightly hard, moderately hard, hard, very hard) is shown alongside the four-band USGS classification.
- Unit conversions use 17.1 mg/L per grain per gallon, 17.85 mg/L per °dH, 10 mg/L per °fH and 100.09 mg/L per mmol/L of calcium carbonate.
- Softener sizing assumes 75 gallons per person per day, regeneration every 7 days, standard capacities from 24,000 to 80,000 grains and 1 lb of salt per 3,000 grains. A dealer will size from your meter and a tap test.
- Water-heater figures scale the Battelle Institute's 2009 per-5-gpg results linearly to this city's hardness and cap at the 48% loss Battelle measured at 30 gpg; the study ran 90-day accelerated tests, not 15 real years.
- Sources: USGS Water Science School, Hardness of Water (classification bands); Water Quality Research Foundation, Battelle study release, April 13 2010 and WQA's Softened Water Benefits Studies page; US EPA, Secondary Drinking Water Standards (TDS 500 mg/L, pH 6.5–8.5) and Consumer Confidence Reports.